
The Genesis of a Local Giant
Founded in 1866, the Eagle Tanning Works stands as the oldest continuous business in Muskegon County. Established by Sam McConnell, the tannery was strategically located on the shores of White Lake, utilizing the abundant local hemlock bark and water supply essential for the tanning process. This site became pivotal for the leather industry, drawing from the region’s vast natural resources.
Evolution Through the Years
Initially, the tannery’s operations involved grinding and bleaching hemlock bark to extract tannic acid, which was vital for producing quality leather. As forests were cleared and hemlock bark became scarce, the company innovated by switching to vegetable tanning methods. The main structure, a robust five-story brick building erected in 1910, signified the company’s growth and commitment to industrial excellence.
In 1912, Pfister and Vogel Leather Company of Milwaukee acquired the Eagle Tanning Works, ensuring its continued prominence in the leather industry. William Hatton, a significant figure in the company’s history, expanded operations and maintained a reputation for producing high-quality leather.

Community and Economic Impact
Throughout its history, Eagle Tanning Works significantly contributed to the local economy, especially during challenging times like the Great Depression. The plant, at its peak, employed over 300 men, providing stability and growth for the Whitehall community. The tannery’s role extended beyond industry; in 1935, Julian B. Hatton, then the general manager, built a combination gymnasium-recreation room, enhancing community life and supporting local athletic teams for over two decades.

Modern Transitions
Despite various ownership changes, including its acquisition by the General Shoe Corporation (now Genesco) in 1944, Eagle Tanning Works remained a crucial part of the local economy. Even after Genesco moved the finishing operations to Tennessee in 1974, the plant continued to employ a substantial workforce, underscoring its enduring economic significance.

Legacy and Preservation
Today, Eagle Tanning Works is a symbol of Muskegon County’s rich industrial heritage. It reflects the region’s ability to adapt and thrive amidst changing economic landscapes, preserving the legacy of the pioneering spirit that marked its inception in the 19th century.
Conclusion
Eagle Tanning Works is more than just a business; it’s a cornerstone of Muskegon County’s history, representing resilience, innovation, and community spirit. Its evolution from a small tannery to a significant industrial player mirrors the broader story of American industry and its impact on local communities.

Interactive White Lake History
As we deliver articles weekly, I challenge you to be curious, explore the local area, and take pictures at these historic locations, and tag CatchMark Community.
Next week we will explore Mears Water Powered Mill – First on White Lake 1837. If you enjoy history and like our content please like and subscribe to our online resources. Also, check out the White Lake Area Historical Society website listed below.
http://www.whitelakeareahistoricalsociety.com/
https://www.facebook.com/CatchMarkCommunity
Owen Raeth joined CatchMark in August 2020 as a Tech Support Intern, then transitioned to DMM to learn graphic design. He is a 2024 graduate of Montague High School. Owen Raeth is a Digital Marketing and Media Intern at CatchMark Technologies with growing experience in video editing, content creation, and drone operations. A 2024 high school graduate, Owen is currently pursuing a degree in English education with a long-term goal of integrating technology into the classroom. Passionate about teaching, communication, and digital tools, he brings strong public speaking skills, hands-on technical ability, and a creative mindset to his work. Owen is committed to bridging education and media to empower future learners.

Must See
-
Latest News
/ 1 day agoHunters and Anglers: Spring Food Plot Tips – What to Plant and Why It Matters
Contributed by Mike Moore, Tines and Trails If you’re thinking about putting in a...
By Kara Raeth -
Community
/ 1 day agoMontague Bike Rodeo Promotes Fun and Safety
The Montague Bike Rodeo rolled into town this past Friday, May 9, 2025, transforming...
By Amy Yonkman -
Community
/ 1 day agoTunes Around Town: May 13–18 Music Lineup
The local music scene continues to shine in Whitehall and Montague! This week, seven...
By Amy Yonkman